NFL

2026 NFL midseason awards expert picks: MVP, Offensive and Defensive Player of the Year, and more

When Monday Night Football concludes to end Week 10, we’ll officially be halfway through the 2026 NFL season. Yes, Week 9 was technically the halfway point of the season, but when the Los Angeles Chargers’ matchup with the Baltimore Ravens is done, every team will have played at least nine games, pushing each squad beyond the halfway mark. 

As such, we have more than enough data points to comb over when looking at the frontrunners for each notable award. 

NFL midseason awards predictions for the 2026 season

From a tight Defensive Rookie of the Year race to a potential repeat Offensive Player of the Year to a big name in the driver’s seat for his first MVP award, we’re here to break down our NFL awards picks thus far. 

Coach of the Year: John Harbaugh, New York Giants

As much as I want to put Jacksonville’s Liam Coen here, I think Harbaugh is the guy. I also think he’ll be front of mind for voters once the time comes assuming the Giants continue on their current pace and win the NFC East. 

Aided in large part by the rest of the division struggling this season, the Giants are in first place in the NFC East. Harbaugh has gotten a lot out of his new team in Year 1, and what makes the job he’s done even more noteworthy is that there’s been a ton of shakeup at quarterback. Jaxson Dart got hurt early, Jameis Winston has gotten some run and now, former first-round bust J.J. McCarthy is under center and playing well for the G-Men. 

Now, I don’t think Harbaugh’s unit has a deep playoff run in them, but being 5-3-1 thus far with a very good defense and a serviceable offense on its third quarterback is a sign of a great head coaching job – especially in Year 1. 

Honorable Mentions: Liam Coen (Jacksonville Jaguars), Ben Johnson (Chicago Bears), Kyle Shanahan (San Francisco 49ers), Todd Monken (Cleveland Browns)

Comeback Player of the Year: Patrick Mahomes, Kansas City Chiefs QB

This one might be the easiest of the bunch. Mahomes did not play up to his standards last year before an ACL tear ended his season prematurely. After doubts about whether or not he’d be ready for Week 1, the three-time Super Bowl MVP was indeed under center, and he’s played great this year. 

Mahomes and the Chiefs are 7-3 overall and he has 20 total touchdowns while averaging 265 passing yards per game. He may not be putting up the video game stats he did in his first few years starting, but Mahomes has bounced back from a very serious injury in a big way and has Kansas City looking like a contender after a poor 2025 showing. 

Honorable Mentions: Malik Nabers (New York Giants WR), Tank Dell (Houston Texans WR), Fred Warner (San Francisco 49ers LB)

Defensive Rookie of the Year: David Bailey Jr., New York Jets DE

This is the hardest one to pick so far. As much as I love the jack-of-all-trades nature of Arvell Reese for the Giants, I’m going to give a slight nod to Bailey. 

The No. 2 overall pick has been a force on the Jets’ defensive line. He’s not just one of the top rookies so far; Bailey is already one of the best pass rushers in the entire NFL. His 7.5 sacks rank tied for seventh in all of football, and Bailey is also tied for fourth in tackles for loss with 10. Bailey is also tied for the NFL lead with five forced fumbles. 

Reese has his share of counting stats as well, including 4.5 sacks as a do-it-all linebacker. If he’s your pick at this stage of the season, I do not fault you whatsoever. I just think Bailey has been a hair better. Regardless, both New York franchises hit home runs with their first-round picks back in April. 

Honorable Mentions: Arvell Reese (New York Giants LB), Sonny Styles (Washington Commanders LB), Jacob Rodriguez (Miami Dolphins LB)

Offensive Rookie of the Year: Denzel Boston, Cleveland Browns WR

This is one that will likely change a lot moving forward with quarterbacks Fernando Mendoza and Carson Beck each having made their first career starts in Week 10. But for now, Boston has been the best offensive rookie in the NFL.

The Washington product has slowed down a bit after a red-hot start to the year, but he’s been an absolute force in Cleveland’s otherwise lackluster passing attack. Boston has more than 500 yards and three touchdowns and has been one of the NFL’s premier deep-ball threats. He has four games with at least one catch of 45 yards or more. 

Boston has stood out in what’s been – so far – an underwhelming rookie class on the offensive side of the football. It looks like the Browns have a long-term receiving duo to envy between Boston and KC Concepcion. 

Honorable Mentions: Carnell Tate (Tennessee Titans WR), KC Concepcion (Cleveland Browns WR), Fernando Mendoza (Las Vegas Raiders QB), Carson Beck (Arizona Cardinals QB)

Defensive Player of the Year: Will Anderson Jr., Houston Texans DE

Anderson was actually my preseason pick for the award, and it’s one that has surprisingly aged very well considering the Texans have regressed tremendously from last year’s squad. 

Anderson is an absolute force on the defensive line. He’s the only player with double-digit sacks right now (10.5), and the former No. 3 overall pick ranks second in tackles for loss. There’s a chance Anderson flirts with 20 sacks when it’s all said and done. 

The Texans’ defense is a far cry from the unit that ranked near the top of the NFL in every major category a year ago, but don’t fault Anderson. He’s putting together the best season of his young career. 

Honorable Mentions: Fred Warner (San Francisco 49ers LB), Jeffery Simmons (Chicago Bears DT), Xavier McKinney (Green Bay Packers S), Greg Rousseau (Buffalo Bills DE)

Offensive Player of the Year: Jaxon Smith-Njigba, Seattle Seahawks WR

JSN is a man possessed. The star Seattle receiver had a year for the ages in 2025 with 119 receptions for 1,793 yards and 10 touchdowns before winning a Super Bowl. He’s on pace to blow those regular-season stats out of the water. 

Through 10 games, Smith-Njigba has 79 catches for 1,207 yards and 10 touchdowns – all of which lead the NFL. He’d be just the sixth receiver in NFL history to win the Triple Crown should he end the year atop those three categories. 

To say JSN is Seattle’s offense is an oversimplification, but not by much. He accounts for more than 50% of the Seahawks’ passing offense this year, and he’s also accounted for nearly 35% of the Seahawks’ total offense this year and is a massive reason the reigning champs are 6-4 entering their bye week. 

No receiver is playing better, and no receiver means more to his team. No running back does, either. 

Honorable Mentions: Ja’Marr Chase (Cincinnati Bengals WR), Jahmyr Gibbs (Detroit Lions RB), Kenneth Walker III (Kansas City Chiefs RB)

Most Valuable Player: Joe Burrow, Cincinnati Bengals QB

After throwing for 409 yards – with 302 in the first half – and five touchdowns against the Steelers on Sunday Night Football, there should be no question that Burrow is the frontrunner for NFL MVP. 

The Cincinnati star has been unstoppable this year, leading the Bengals to a 7-2 start. Burrow leads the NFL with 27 touchdown passes and is second in passing yards at 2,795. He’s been accurate, decisive, dangerous and, most importantly, a winner. 

The Bengals have long had arguably the NFL’s best receiver duo in Ja’Marr Chase and Tee Higgins, but it has always seemed one of those two and/or Burrow has been hurt. With all three healthy, the Bengals’ passing attack is as dangerous as they come. 

What’s more, Cincy has no run game to speak of, so Burrow has to be elite for this team to win. He’s done that and more, and it’s clear he’s the MVP at this point of 2026. 

Honorable Mentions: Josh Allen (Buffalo Bills QB), Brock Purdy (San Francisco 49ers QB), Jaxon Smith-Njigba (Seattle Seahawks WR)

Brandon Gustafson

Brandon Gustafson

Brandon Gustafson is an MLB, NFL and college football analyst for SeatGeek. A former college baseball pitcher, Brandon has worked full-time in sports media since 2019 covering MLB, NFL and more with stops at Seattle Sports 710 AM, Pro Football Network and currently CBS Sports. Brandon lives in the greater-Seattle area with his wife and son.